blackshoe, on 2012-April-03, 06:41, said:
Yes, I know.
As I understand it, you have made three different arguments.
(1) The current Laws don't allow you ask the meanings of future calls.
(2) Nobody will ever need to know the meanings of future calls.
(3) It would be impractical to allow people to ask about future calls.
I agree with you about (1), but not about (2) or (3).
It seems to me that every time I respond to your arguments (2) or (3), you counter by repeating (1). That doesn't much help us in discussing (2) and (3).
Quote
If this were legal (which I agree it isn't), I think it would go
"What does 2NT mean please?"
"Game-forcing with four card support."
"What are the three-level rebids?"
"New suits show shortage, 3♥ shows a semi-balanced non-minimum, 3NT shows 18-19 balanced."
"Thank you."
I don't understand why one would need the director.